Volume 1 · The Machine Between the Ears · Essay 192
Mental Asterisk
Every confident statement in your head deserves a small mark after it — the asterisk that says: conditions apply. The mind hates asterisks; it prefers its conclusions clean. But accuracy lives in the fine print.
Watch how thoughts arrive: "she dislikes me." "I am bad at this." "This will fail." Each arrives as a verdict. Add the asterisk and the same thoughts become honest: "she dislikes me — based on one meeting." "I am bad at this — so far, with no training." "This will fail — assuming nothing changes." The asterisk does not reverse the thought. It restores the evidence.
This is not timidity. The marksmanship of thought is knowing which conclusions deserve full type and which deserve the small star.
So practice appending it, especially to the thoughts that arrive with the most certainty. Strong feeling is not strong evidence — it is usually a sign the asterisk was dropped. Put it back. The footnote, in thinking as in scholarship, is where the truth keeps its office.